Medina Weighs Youth E-Bike Helmet Rule, Sidewalk Safety and Data Center Limits
City Council — Medina
Medina council members back helmets for e-bike riders 17 and under while officials say the city lacks the land and power for a hyperscale data center.
Medina City Council members used a special legislation session on Tuesday, Nov. 17 to take on two topics residents have been raising: e-bikes and data centers. All of council attended, along with the mayor and administration. Several residents came to listen. No formal votes were taken at the informational session. Members did agree to bring a helmet requirement for young riders before the full council. Helmet Rule for Riders 17 and Under Heads to Council Councilwoman Natalie Harjar-DiSalvo led the session. She opened by showing the city’s current sidewalk rule, which dates to 1987. It bans bicycles, skateboards, mopeds, motorized vehicles and toy vehicles on public sidewalks within one block of Medina Square. She then reviewed Ohio Senate Bill 477, now in committee at the Statehouse. The state proposal includes registration requirements, a minimum riding age of 14 and a broad helmet mandate. She called the bill very complex. Harjar-DiSalvo said Medina would not take up age limits or private property use for now. Instead, she proposed a local rule requiring helmets for anyone under 17 riding an e-bike or low-speed micromobility device on a public thoroughfare. Those devices include e-scooters, one-wheel skateboards and Segways. “If they are on a public thoroughfare, they need to have a helmet,” she said. Councilwoman Regi Haire supported the idea. She noted that injuries have risen along with the popularity of the devices. Councilman Bill Lamb called the requirement a smart, timely step. He said many young riders won’t wear helmets unless required. Haire made the motion to move the rule forward for riders 17 and under. She suggested helmets meet Consumer Product Safety Commission standards. The police chief asked that the exact helmet language be researched before it reaches council. Assistant Law Director Matt Lanier, who was not at the meeting, was suggested for that work. Sidewalk Conflicts Remain a Concern Council President John Coyne III said he submitted the legislation and supports helmets. He argued the bigger problem is riders speeding past people on sidewalks across the city. Coyne said residents in every ward have told him they’ve had to jump out of the way. He doubted a full sidewalk ban would work. He asked for some type of consequence for riders who interfere with pedestrians. Harjar-DiSalvo pointed out that SB 477 proposes speed caps. Those would be 10 mph on shared use paths, 5 mph on sidewalks for micromobility devices and 20 mph on streets. Coyne questioned how any city could enforce that. Harjar-DiSalvo agreed, saying riders would override speed governors anyway. What Police Can Enforce Today The police chief said riding an e-bike on a sidewalk under electric power is already illegal under state law. Pedaling is allowed. “If they’re peddling it’s legal. If they’re under electric power, it’s illegal,” he said. He said officers can’t easily tell an e-bike’s class or a rider’s age from a passing cruiser. So they focus on obvious violations, like powered riding on sidewalks. E-motos are another target. The chief described them as electric motorcycles with foot pegs and no pedals. They are illegal on streets and sidewalks unless registered and ridden by a licensed operator. Parents can be held responsible for wrongful entrustment. He said officers ran a dedicated e-bike patrol over the summer. First stops are treated as education. Repeat offenders get citations. Education Over Citations The chief recommended an education campaign. He also cautioned against rules so strict they push children off sidewalks and into busy streets. Mayor Jim Shields said a safety chart from Medina police made such an impression on Medina City Schools that the district sent it to about 7,500 parents. He called it very effective. Coyne asked whether young offenders could attend a safety class instead of paying a ticket. The chief said the city already has a juvenile diversion program for traffic offenders. He also urged parents to think carefully before buying an e-bike or e-moto as a Christmas gift this year. Lamb suggested buying a helmet too. The Square’s New Path Is Not a Sidewalk Coyne asked how the new 10-foot path on the square fits with the sidewalk ban. The chief said the city’s ordinance allows e-bikes on multi-use paths. By definition, that path is not a sidewalk. Why Medina Is an Unlikely Data Center Site Harjar-DiSalvo then shifted to data centers. She opened by playing a recording of the noise a hyperscale data center makes. Economic Development Director Kimberly Marshall said hyperscale centers like those used by Meta, Amazon and Google need roughly 500 to 600 acres. Medina has nothing that size. Marshall said the city’s largest industrial land sits in the Cooperative Economic Development Agreement area annexed from York Township. A developer would have to assemble about 255 acres there. The nearest power lines carry 69 kilovolts. A hyperscale site needs a 345-kilovolt line, which is far away. She said